Novated Lease Pros and Cons: The Honest List to Read Before You Sign

Updated 10 minute read

Most lists of novated lease pros and cons are written to sell you one. The pros get the detail, the cons get a sentence each, and the numbers that actually decide whether it’s worth it never show up.

This list does it differently. Every pro and every con below is weighed against hard figures: the 2026–27 ATO tax rates, the ATO’s minimum residual values, how fringe benefits tax (FBT) works on petrol and electric cars, and what fees really cost over a five-year lease. Some of the cons are real deal-breakers for some people. You should know which ones before you sign anything.

Novated Lease Pros and Cons at a Glance

ProsCons
Less income tax every payA residual (balloon) payment at the end
No GST on the purchase pricePetrol and hybrid cars need post-tax contributions
Eligible EVs are currently FBT exemptFees and margins can be hard to see
Running costs bundled and paid pre-taxThe lease stays with you if you change jobs
No deposit and no business-use rulesReportable fringe benefits can affect other things
Flexible options when the lease endsYour employer has to offer it

The Pros of a Novated Lease

1. You pay less income tax every pay

This is the big one. Your lease payments and running costs come out of your salary before tax is calculated, so you’re taxed on a smaller income. The saving depends on your marginal rate. Under the 2026–27 resident tax rates, every $1,000 moved pre-tax saves $170 if you earn between $18,201 and $45,000, $320 between $45,001 and $135,000, and $390 between $135,001 and $190,000 (all including the 2% Medicare levy).

The numbers: on a $100,000 salary with a $17,000-a-year package for an FBT-exempt electric car, you’d pay about $5,440 less tax a year, or roughly $209 a fortnight. That’s the same car and the same running costs, just paid from a different part of your pay.

2. You don’t pay GST on the car

The finance company buys the car and claims back the GST, so you lease it at the GST-exclusive price. That’s a saving of up to 9.09% of the drive-away price, capped at $6,353 for 2026–27 (one-eleventh of the ATO car limit of $69,883). On a $50,000 car, that’s about $4,545 you never finance. GST is also removed from most running costs, like servicing and tyres.

3. Eligible electric cars are currently FBT exempt

Battery electric cars priced under the fuel-efficient luxury car tax threshold ($91,661 for 2026–27) are exempt from FBT. That means your whole package can usually come out pre-tax, which is why EVs deliver the biggest savings on a novated lease.

There’s a deadline attached. The Government has proposed winding the exemption back for arrangements entered into from 1 April 2027: cars with a value of $75,000 or less would stay fully exempt until 1 April 2029, while pricier EVs would only get a 25% FBT discount. According to the ATO’s summary of the proposed change, existing leases won’t be affected. Draft legislation was released in September 2026, but at the time of writing it isn’t law yet.

4. Running costs are bundled into one deduction

A fully maintained novated lease rolls fuel or charging, servicing, tyres, registration, insurance and roadside assistance into the same pay deduction. You get the tax benefit on those costs too, and you stop juggling separate bills. A fuel or charging card covers the day-to-day spend.

5. No deposit and no business-use requirement

You don’t need savings for a deposit, and you don’t need to use the car for work. Most people use their novated car entirely for private driving: commuting, school runs, weekends away. There’s no logbook to keep for an exempt EV.

6. You have options when the lease ends

At the end of the term you can pay the residual and keep the car, refinance the residual into a new lease on the same car, or trade it in and start again with a new one. If the car is worth more than the residual when you sell, you generally keep the difference.

The Cons of a Novated Lease

1. You’ll owe a residual (balloon) payment

Every novated lease ends with a residual payment. The ATO sets minimum residual values based on the lease term, and they’re bigger than many people expect. Here’s what they look like on a $50,000 car:

Lease termATO minimum residualResidual on a $50,000 car
1 year65.63%$32,815
2 years56.25%$28,125
3 years46.88%$23,440
4 years37.50%$18,750
5 years28.13%$14,065

The honest take: the residual isn’t a hidden cost, it’s the part of the car you haven’t paid off yet. But you need a plan for it from day one. Paying it out with after-tax money, refinancing it or trading the car are all fine. Getting to the end of the lease and having no plan isn’t.

2. Petrol, diesel and hybrid cars need post-tax contributions

Cars that aren’t FBT exempt create a fringe benefit. To avoid paying FBT, most providers use the Employee Contribution Method: you pay part of your package from after-tax salary. Under the ATO’s statutory formula, the taxable value of a car fringe benefit is 20% of the car’s base value each year, less what you contribute after tax.

The numbers: for a petrol car with a $50,000 base value, $10,000 a year has to come from post-tax pay. On the same $100,000 salary and $17,000 package as above, only $7,000 stays pre-tax, so your tax saving drops from $5,440 to about $2,240 a year. Still a saving (plus the GST benefit), but less than half the EV result. Plug-in hybrids lost the FBT exemption on 1 April 2025 unless the arrangement was already in place, so they fall into this group too.

3. Fees and margins can be hard to see

This is the con most lists skip. A novated lease quote often bundles finance, running costs and provider fees into one per-pay figure. Monthly management fees, establishment fees, brokerage built into the interest rate, and generous running-cost budgets can all sit inside that number without being itemised.

Small differences add up over a five-year term. On a $45,455 lease (a $50,000 car, ex-GST) with a 28.13% residual, an interest rate just 1% higher costs about $1,525 more across the five years. That’s the same as paying an extra $25 a month in fees.

For comparison, Auto Deduct charges a flat $10 a month in fees, with no hidden costs. That’s $120 a year, or $600 over a five-year lease. But a low fee is only one part of an honest quote. Whoever you get a quote from, ask for:

  • The interest rate and the comparison rate on the finance component.
  • Every fee in dollars: establishment, monthly, and end-of-lease or early termination.
  • Whether any brokerage or commission is built into the rate.
  • The running costs budget, line by line, and whether unspent money is refunded.

If a provider can’t answer those clearly, that tells you something.

4. The lease follows you if you change jobs

The novation agreement ties your employer to the payments only while you work there. If you resign, are made redundant or change jobs, the lease comes back to you. Payments switch to your own after-tax income until a new employer agrees to take it on, and you lose the tax benefit in the meantime. If you want out entirely, you’ll need to pay out the lease, which can include early termination costs. If your job feels uncertain, factor this in before choosing a long term.

5. Reportable fringe benefits can affect other things

Even an FBT-exempt EV appears as a reportable fringe benefit on your income statement. It doesn’t increase your income tax, but it’s counted for some income tests, including HELP and student loan repayments, the Medicare levy surcharge and some government payments and child support assessments. Your take-home pay will also look lower on your payslip, which some lenders notice when you apply for a home loan.

6. Your employer has to offer it, and not everyone is eligible

A novated lease needs an employer willing to run the deductions through payroll. Most will if they’re asked, because it costs them nothing (see how it works for employers), but it’s still their call. Sole traders without a PAYG salary, contractors and casuals on irregular hours generally can’t novate a lease. Company directors who pay themselves a wage often can, including in a one-person company, which is covered on our small business page.

Who a Novated Lease Suits (and Who It Doesn’t)

Weighing up the novated lease pros and cons above, a lease tends to stack up when:

  • You’re a permanent PAYG employee earning above $45,000, where the 30% marginal rate kicks in.
  • You’re choosing an eligible EV, especially before the proposed 1 April 2027 change.
  • You drive enough that running costs make up a decent share of the package.
  • Your job is stable for at least the length of the lease.

It’s harder to justify if you earn under $45,000, expect to change jobs soon, want a petrol car with a high base value and drive very little, or are about to apply for a home loan and need your payslip to look as strong as possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the biggest disadvantage of a novated lease?

For most people it’s the residual payment combined with the lease following you if you leave your job. Both are manageable if you plan for them, but they’re the two things that catch people out.

Is a novated lease worth it?

For PAYG employees on a 30% marginal rate or higher, a novated lease is usually cheaper than buying the same car with an after-tax loan, once income tax and GST savings are counted. The margin is biggest on FBT-exempt EVs. A quote that shows your per-pay deductions and every fee is the only way to know for your situation.

Does a novated lease reduce my super?

No. Since 1 January 2020, employers must calculate your superannuation guarantee on your earnings before salary sacrifice, so packaging a car doesn’t reduce your compulsory super contributions.

Can a novated lease affect my home loan application?

It can. Lenders see a lower take-home figure on your payslip and treat the lease as an ongoing commitment. Talk to your broker or lender about how they assess it before you sign if a home loan is on the horizon.

What happens if I lose my job during a novated lease?

The lease obligations return to you. You can keep making payments from your own income, transfer the lease to a new employer when you start a new role, or pay out the lease, which may include early termination costs.

The Bottom Line

The pros of a novated lease are real: less tax, no GST on the car, and a big advantage on eligible EVs while the current FBT exemption lasts. The cons are real too. There’s a residual to plan for, post-tax contributions on non-exempt cars, a lease that follows you between jobs, and fees that some providers make hard to find.

The good news is that every one of those cons can be checked before you sign. See the full range of novated lease benefits for employees, or get a personalised quote from Auto Deduct. We’ll show your per-pay deductions, your residual and every fee in dollars, with no pressure and no obligation.

This article is general information only and doesn’t take into account your personal circumstances. Figures are illustrative and based on 2026–27 resident tax rates. Proposed FBT changes are not yet law. Consider seeking independent tax or financial advice before entering a novated lease.

This article is general information only. It doesn’t take your personal circumstances into account and isn’t financial, tax or legal advice. Consider getting independent advice before you make a decision.

See how much you could save

Tell us a little about yourself and the car you’re after, and one of our team will get back to you with your numbers.

  • A personalised savings estimate
  • No obligation to go ahead
  • Phone or email, whichever suits you